CARFOCALvehicle research
Research CarsCompareRankingsArticles
  1. Home
  2. Manufacturers
  3. Rankings
  4. Carfocal Overall Score Index

CarFocal Research Desk

Carfocal Overall Score Index

Compare U.S. car and truck brands using buyer-focused research on reliability, recalls, ownership costs, and real-world risk—then open the model-year guide before you commit.

46 Brands Ranked
6025 Vehicles Analyzed
Updated July 5, 2026
Overall ScoreAll measures combinedReliability IndexRecall & complaint dataOwnership RiskLong-term cost exposure

Full Rankings

Higher score is better. Ties occur only on exact score matches.

EliteExcellentGoodAverage
RankManufacturerOverall ScoreAvg ReliabilityAvg MaintenanceAvg PracticalityVehicles
1
Mazda
Good
7.0
8.38.55.0113View Models
2
Mercedes-Benz
Good
6.9
9.09.25.3446View Models
2
Honda
Good
6.9
8.68.95.4234View Models
2
Capacity Trucks
Good
6.9
8.89.43.8140View Models
2
Yamaha
Good
6.9
8.89.55.033View Models
6
Mitsubishi
Good
6.8
8.58.75.477View Models
6
Suzuki
Good
6.8
8.59.25.154View Models
6
Maserati
Good
6.8
8.17.74.352View Models
6
RIVIAN
Good
6.8
7.48.66.413View Models
10
Nissan
Good
6.7
8.48.35.3267View Models
10
Kia
Good
6.7
7.98.45.4170View Models
10
Porsche
Good
6.7
7.87.94.0105View Models
10
MINI
Good
6.7
8.78.95.277View Models
10
Aston Martin
Good
6.7
8.37.24.470View Models
10
Tesla
Good
6.7
6.28.36.447View Models
10
Ferrari
Good
6.7
8.36.44.737View Models
17
Ram
Good
6.6
8.18.65.584View Models
17
Buick
Good
6.6
7.58.35.080View Models
17
smart
Good
6.6
8.68.94.315View Models
20
BMW
Good
6.5
8.38.25.2619View Models
20
Toyota
Good
6.5
7.67.95.4329View Models
20
Lexus
Good
6.5
8.48.56.2162View Models
20
Infiniti
Good
6.5
8.38.54.8115View Models
20
Jeep
Good
6.5
8.18.45.0103View Models
20
Lincoln
Good
6.5
7.68.24.991View Models
26
Chevrolet
Average
6.4
7.68.35.3283View Models
26
GMC
Average
6.4
7.58.35.1122View Models
26
Subaru
Average
6.4
7.17.64.9122View Models
26
Cadillac
Average
6.4
7.28.24.9116View Models
26
McLaren
Average
6.4
8.03.94.617View Models
31
Hyundai
Average
6.3
7.08.35.3188View Models
31
Volkswagen
Average
6.3
7.27.64.9182View Models
31
Volvo
Average
6.3
7.78.55.1134View Models
31
Acura
Average
6.3
6.98.04.999View Models
31
Rolls-Royce
Average
6.3
8.68.14.357View Models
31
Alfa Romeo
Average
6.3
8.08.64.829View Models
31
Fiat
Average
6.3
7.68.44.929View Models
38
Audi
Average
6.2
7.88.24.6402View Models
38
Dodge
Average
6.2
6.98.24.987View Models
38
Genesis
Average
6.2
6.98.34.743View Models
38
Lamborghini
Average
6.2
8.34.23.425View Models
42
Bentley
Average
6.1
8.27.14.450View Models
42
Chrysler
Average
6.1
6.38.24.845View Models
44
Ford
Average
6.0
6.97.14.9297View Models
45
Land Rover
Average
5.9
7.38.04.997View Models
45
Jaguar
Average
5.9
7.38.04.668View Models
  • 1
    Mazda
    7.0Good
    Reliability: 8.3Maintenance: 8.5
    View Models
  • 2
    Mercedes-Benz
    6.9Good
    Reliability: 9.0Maintenance: 9.2
    View Models
  • 2
    Honda
    6.9Good
    Reliability: 8.6Maintenance: 8.9
    View Models
  • 2
    Capacity Trucks
    6.9Good
    Reliability: 8.8Maintenance: 9.4
    View Models
  • 2
    Yamaha
    6.9Good
    Reliability: 8.8Maintenance: 9.5
    View Models
  • 6
    Mitsubishi
    6.8Good
    Reliability: 8.5Maintenance: 8.7
    View Models
  • 6
    Suzuki
    6.8Good
    Reliability: 8.5Maintenance: 9.2
    View Models
  • 6
    Maserati
    6.8Good
    Reliability: 8.1Maintenance: 7.7
    View Models
  • 6
    RIVIAN
    6.8Good
    Reliability: 7.4Maintenance: 8.6
    View Models
  • 10
    Nissan
    6.7Good
    Reliability: 8.4Maintenance: 8.3
    View Models
  • 10
    Kia
    6.7Good
    Reliability: 7.9Maintenance: 8.4
    View Models
  • 10
    Porsche
    6.7Good
    Reliability: 7.8Maintenance: 7.9
    View Models
  • 10
    MINI
    6.7Good
    Reliability: 8.7Maintenance: 8.9
    View Models
  • 10
    Aston Martin
    6.7Good
    Reliability: 8.3Maintenance: 7.2
    View Models
  • 10
    Tesla
    6.7Good
    Reliability: 6.2Maintenance: 8.3
    View Models
  • 10
    Ferrari
    6.7Good
    Reliability: 8.3Maintenance: 6.4
    View Models
  • 17
    Ram
    6.6Good
    Reliability: 8.1Maintenance: 8.6
    View Models
  • 17
    Buick
    6.6Good
    Reliability: 7.5Maintenance: 8.3
    View Models
  • 17
    smart
    6.6Good
    Reliability: 8.6Maintenance: 8.9
    View Models
  • 20
    BMW
    6.5Good
    Reliability: 8.3Maintenance: 8.2
    View Models
  • 20
    Toyota
    6.5Good
    Reliability: 7.6Maintenance: 7.9
    View Models
  • 20
    Lexus
    6.5Good
    Reliability: 8.4Maintenance: 8.5
    View Models
  • 20
    Infiniti
    6.5Good
    Reliability: 8.3Maintenance: 8.5
    View Models
  • 20
    Jeep
    6.5Good
    Reliability: 8.1Maintenance: 8.4
    View Models
  • 20
    Lincoln
    6.5Good
    Reliability: 7.6Maintenance: 8.2
    View Models
  • 26
    Chevrolet
    6.4Average
    Reliability: 7.6Maintenance: 8.3
    View Models
  • 26
    GMC
    6.4Average
    Reliability: 7.5Maintenance: 8.3
    View Models
  • 26
    Subaru
    6.4Average
    Reliability: 7.1Maintenance: 7.6
    View Models
  • 26
    Cadillac
    6.4Average
    Reliability: 7.2Maintenance: 8.2
    View Models
  • 26
    McLaren
    6.4Average
    Reliability: 8.0Maintenance: 3.9
    View Models
  • 31
    Hyundai
    6.3Average
    Reliability: 7.0Maintenance: 8.3
    View Models
  • 31
    Volkswagen
    6.3Average
    Reliability: 7.2Maintenance: 7.6
    View Models
  • 31
    Volvo
    6.3Average
    Reliability: 7.7Maintenance: 8.5
    View Models
  • 31
    Acura
    6.3Average
    Reliability: 6.9Maintenance: 8.0
    View Models
  • 31
    Rolls-Royce
    6.3Average
    Reliability: 8.6Maintenance: 8.1
    View Models
  • 31
    Alfa Romeo
    6.3Average
    Reliability: 8.0Maintenance: 8.6
    View Models
  • 31
    Fiat
    6.3Average
    Reliability: 7.6Maintenance: 8.4
    View Models
  • 38
    Audi
    6.2Average
    Reliability: 7.8Maintenance: 8.2
    View Models
  • 38
    Dodge
    6.2Average
    Reliability: 6.9Maintenance: 8.2
    View Models
  • 38
    Genesis
    6.2Average
    Reliability: 6.9Maintenance: 8.3
    View Models
  • 38
    Lamborghini
    6.2Average
    Reliability: 8.3Maintenance: 4.2
    View Models
  • 42
    Bentley
    6.1Average
    Reliability: 8.2Maintenance: 7.1
    View Models
  • 42
    Chrysler
    6.1Average
    Reliability: 6.3Maintenance: 8.2
    View Models
  • 44
    Ford
    6.0Average
    Reliability: 6.9Maintenance: 7.1
    View Models
  • 45
    Land Rover
    5.9Average
    Reliability: 7.3Maintenance: 8.0
    View Models
  • 45
    Jaguar
    5.9Average
    Reliability: 7.3Maintenance: 8.0
    View Models

Found a brand worth considering? Check the model year next.

Brand rankings narrow the field. The model-year guide helps you decide whether the exact car is worth a test drive, inspection, or offer.

Research a model

Questions shoppers ask before choosing a brand

Clear answers about what the ranking measures—and how to use it without over-trusting a single score.

What does the CarFocal Carfocal Overall Score Index tell shoppers?

Static global manufacturer ranking based on the buyer-guide overall vehicle score. It ranks 46 manufacturers using data from 6025 eligible vehicles, giving you a starting point for a lower-risk shortlist—not a verdict on every individual car.

View ranking table
How is the Carfocal Overall Score Index calculated?

The ranking combines aggregated reliability scores, maintenance costs, recall volumes, and complaint frequencies across each manufacturer's eligible lineup. Validate the exact model year, VIN, service history, and inspection before buying.

Read full methodology
Which car brands rank highest in the Carfocal Overall Score Index?

The top-ranked manufacturers in this index prioritize overall vehicle quality and reliability across their tracked model years.

See top brands

How the ranking is built

  • Use the same buyer-guide overall formula already shown on Carfocal vehicle pages.
  • Compute each vehicle score from the average of valid maintenance, tuning, and practicality scores.
  • Include a vehicle when at least one of those component scores is available.
  • Rank manufacturers by the average overall score across all eligible vehicles in scope.
Want the deep dive? Read the full methodology

Comparing a specific car?

Move from a brand-level score to the exact model year, with reliability, recalls, common problems, and maintenance context in one place.

Find the model guide

Why shoppers use CarFocal

This report rolls up the same overall vehicle scoring logic used on vehicle reports, averaging maintenance, tuning, and practicality data.

Sources & MethodsAbout CarFocal

Research updates

  1. v1.0 2026-03-21

    Initial manufacturer ranking based on the average buyer-guide overall score across eligible vehicles.

Find a car report

Carfocal

Automotive Research

Real data on vehicle reliability, safety, and ownership costs.

  • Used Car Research
  • Reliability Rankings
  • Buying Guides

  • Data Sources & Methodology
  • Editorial Standards
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Legal Disclosures
  • Terms of Service

© 2026 Carfocal · All Rights Reserved