What are the most common problems with the 2023 Tesla Model Y?

The most significant concern for used 2023 Model Y buyers is 'phantom braking,' sudden and unexpected deceleration events impacting driver confidence and safety.

How many recalls does the 2023 Tesla Model Y have?

The 2023 Tesla Model Y currently has 26 recalls on file. Review the full recall report to see affected components and available remedies.

Is the 2023 Tesla Model Y a good buy used?

Verdict: High risk. The most significant concern for used 2023 Model Y buyers is 'phantom braking,' sudden and unexpected deceleration events impacting driver confidence and safety. Numerous recalls and a high complaint volume related to **steering** and **forward collision avoidance** systems warrant careful pre-purchase inspection. Despite advanced technology, the vehicle's reliability verdict is 'Below Average,' demanding vigilance from potential owners. Owners should be aware of potential limitations in parking assist and object detection due to the removal of ultrasonic sensors. Regular software updates are crucial, but their effectiveness in resolving core issues like phantom braking remains a point of concern. Always verify service history, open recalls, and maintenance records before purchasing.

What maintenance costs should I expect for the 2023 Tesla Model Y?

Refer to the maintenance cost guide for interval schedules, DIY difficulty ratings, and typical repair cost ranges for the 2023 Tesla Model Y.

2023 Tesla Model Y Report

Known issues, recalls, running costs, and what to check before you buy.

Updated May 30, 2026Daniel Wilson5 Critical Recalls

Overall Score

Our Verdict

High risk

Key Takeaways

The most significant concern for used 2023 Model Y buyers is 'phantom braking,' sudden and unexpected deceleration events impacting driver confidence and safety.
Numerous recalls and a high complaint volume related to steering and forward collision avoidance systems warrant careful pre-purchase inspection.
Despite advanced technology, the vehicle's reliability verdict is 'Below Average,' demanding vigilance from potential owners.
Owners should be aware of potential limitations in parking assist and object detection due to the removal of ultrasonic sensors.

See the 5 checks before you buyFree • Takes 20s • Saves Thousands $

Overview

2023 Tesla Model Y

The 2023 Tesla Model Y offers a glimpse into the electric future, but for the used car shopper, its appeal is tempered by significant reliability concerns. While its electric powertrain provides instant torque and a minimalist interior, the prevalence of 'phantom braking' – sudden, unintended deceleration – is a major red flag. This issue impacts critical systems like adaptive cruise control and automatic emergency braking, often occurring without warning. Furthermore, numerous recalls affecting steering and electrical components suggest potential systemic quality control challenges. Buyers should approach this model with caution, prioritizing thorough inspections of its advanced safety systems and steering components.

Critical Failure Risk

Sudden, unexpected deceleration events, often occurring without apparent cause or warning, impacting Adaptive Cruise Control, Automatic Emergency Braking, and Vehicle Speed Control. This is the most prevalent and concerning issue for the Model Y.

Early detection can help you avoid a $500-$2,000 repair.

Open Maintenance Analysis →

Safety & Bulletins

Open Recalls26

Service Bulletins0

Full Recall History →

Owner Complaints

1700

Forward Collision Avoidance: Adaptive Cruise Control275

Detailed Issue Breakdown →

Performance & Efficiency

Full Vehicle Specifications ↓

Reliability

Practicality

The score is supported by solid day-to-day usability signals.

Buyer Fit

Who This Car Is For

Best for

Tech-savvy buyers prioritizing electric vehicle technology and minimalist design.

+2 more buyer-fit notes in the full report

Avoid if

Drivers seeking a completely trouble-free ownership experience.

+2 more buyer-fit warnings in the full report

2023 Tesla Model Y Reliability Analysis

Specs

Vehicle Specs

Seating Capacity: 5
Transmission: Automatic
Body Style: Suv

CarFocal account required

See the full 2023 Tesla Model Y buyer report before you decide

Unlock the complete checklist, maintenance outlook, and buyer verdict in one place.

Most Common Issues

1. FORWARD COLLISION AVOIDANCE: ADAPTIVE CRUISE CONTROL

Most reported

Usage: 275 reports

2. FORWARD COLLISION AVOIDANCE: AUTOMATIC EMERGENCY BRAKING

Usage: 216 reports

See all common issues in the maintenance guide

First Service Interval

- Tire Rotation (Parts: Brake Cleaner, Lubricant) - Cabin Air Filter Replacement (Parts: Cabin Air Filter)

Est. shop cost: $100 - $200

10,000 mi

Unlock the full maintenance guide for every scheduled service interval and cost forecast.

Full pre-purchase inspection checklist

Complete maintenance schedule (4 service intervals)

Repair forecasts with mileage and cost context

Full buyer-fit guidance and who should avoid it

Full specs and trim-level context

26 recall campaign details & remedy notes

Create free account

Free • Takes 20 seconds • Saves Thousands $

Already have an account? Log in

FAQ

Is the 2023 Tesla Model Y reliable?

The CarFocal Reliability Score for the 2023 Tesla Model Y is 2.3/10. Reliability score is 2.3/10. NHTSA recalls: 26. Owner complaints: 1,700.

How practical is the 2023 Tesla Model Y for daily use?

Practicality score is 9.0/10. The score is supported by solid day-to-day usability signals. Seating capacity is 5. 4 passenger doors are listed. Boot capacity is 854 litres.

What is the overall score for the 2023 Tesla Model Y?

The CarFocal Overall Score for the 2023 Tesla Model Y is 5.8/10. Overall score is 5.8/10 (Mixed). Confidence 38%. Maintenance 7.7/10. Practicality 9.0/10.

What does it cost to own and maintain a 2023 Tesla Model Y?

Based on Carfocal's data, First listed service: - Tire Rotation (Parts: Brake Cleaner, Lubricant) - Cabin Air Filter Replacement (Parts: Cabin Air Filter) at 10,000 miles. Estimated first-year maintenance: $150 - $300. Repair prediction highlight: Forward Collision Avoidance System (Software/Sensors) (typical at 500 miles, estimated cost Min: $0 • Max: $500).

What transmission does the 2023 Tesla Model Y use?

According to CarFocal's specs for the 2023 Tesla Model Y, transmission is Automatic.

What driver assistance and safety features are available on the 2023 Tesla Model Y?

16 standard and 2 optional driver assistance features. Key features include Anti-lock Braking System, Electronic Stability Control, Traction Control.

How many people fit in a 2023 Tesla Model Y?

According to CarFocal's specs for the 2023 Tesla Model Y, seating capacity is 5.

What body style is the 2023 Tesla Model Y?

According to CarFocal's specs for the 2023 Tesla Model Y, body style is suv.

What are the most common forward collision avoidance: adaptive cruise control problems on the 2023 Tesla Model Y?

Top complaint category: forward collision avoidance: adaptive cruise control (275 reports, 16.2% of complaints).

Are there open safety recalls on the 2023 Tesla Model Y?

This model year has 26 official safety campaigns listed.

Should buyers consider alternatives to the 2023 Tesla Model Y?

Alternatives listed in this guide: 2023 Ford Mustang Mach-E and 2023 Hyundai Ioniq 5.